EQUIPMENT
NECESSARY AND DESIRABLE FOR TL AND OSL DATING
In setting up a laboratory for TL dating, a
number of instruments and pieces of laboratory apparatus are absolutely
necessary. Some are necessary for
certain measurements but need not belong to the TL lab, and some are helpful or
labor-saving but not truly necessary for determining TL ages. The following list of the major apparatus
needed gives a short explanation of why required, and whether it is
necessary. In some cases, where
equipment is available elsewhere, such as radiation sources, it may be possible
to begin dating with only the TL reader, software, computer, and atmosphere
control (vacuum pump and purge gas supply).
However, this can limit the amount of work possible and makes one
dependent on others' schedules.
The choice of base system will depend largely on
whether you will be doing any substantial amount of TL measurement, where an
evacuable system is, depending on sample materials, either optional or
necessary. While the most versatile of
our systems, the 1100, can accomplish both TL and OSL measurements very well,
the new 2200 high capacity OSL system is the better choice where the primary
technique is OSL, and especially where TL capability already exists in the
lab. The 1150 high capacity TL system
is designed for additive dose geological measurement where the irradiations are
external; now that single aliquot OSL techniques that require multiple
irradiations are popular, this is not the best choice. It should also be mentioned that the single
aliquot techniques are quite time consuming since there are so many lengthy
irradiations. A platter load of 20
disks may take from a day to two weeks to finish, so that high capacity is
really not an issue.
The recommendations for TL and OSL are given
separately below.
1. TL
reader system. The 1100 is a
general-purpose automated reader that accommodates 20 samples, and can take all
the accessory systems, including
irradiators and OSL exciters. It also
can be used in the single sample mode
(as in the 1000 system). While beta
irradiations can be done on the 1100 (with the irradiation port and sample
elevator, and a 740 beta irradiator plus Sr-90 source), it is recommended that
the 801 multiple sample alpha/beta irradiator be used instead since samples
should preferably be irradiated and held for 12-24 hours at 100-150C to remove
any fading component. This is
particularly important for archaeological dating, but in some cases is
necessary for authenticity dating as well, when there is considerable anomalous
fading. An alternative option for
on-instrument irradiation, especially attractive for authenticity dating and
single aliquot techniques, is the model 770 beta irradiator/transfer arm, which
moves the irradiator to the 1100 only when required, thus avoiding the
troublesome elevated dark count from bremstrahlen radiation from a nearby
source. The preheat capability of the
ramp cycle can be used to remove part of the fading, but generally not
all. When a great number of samples will
be measured (as in geological dating), a higher capacity reader system is very
desirable. The Daybreak model 1150 has
a 57-sample capacity, but does not permit irradiations on the instrument. The IRIS4 quad detector permits recording
glowcurves in four wavelength passbands simultaneously, and is useful for
characterizing sample emission. An
efficient quartz light guide system with large input aperture makes it
considerably more efficient than wavelength dispersive systems.
2. TLAPPLIC/FirstLight
software. This software package is
necessary to run the 1100 TL system,
and includes not only data-taking functions, but also complete display, subtraction, filtering, shifting, and data
analysis. Data analysis includes not
only growth curve analysis for archaeological dating, but all current methods
of geological dating as well with a very comprehensive fitting suite, plus a
complete age computation with error analysis.
The TLAPPLIC license covers up to three TL systems in a laboratory,
and there are free upgrades for two
years. A Windows version, FirstLight,
is to released in January 2001, and is a general purpose application for TL,
OSL, and, shortly, ESR. It is a major step up from the DOS version, basically a
database-centered application, and virtually free of restrictions on size or
contents. The fitting suite includes
linear, saturating exponential, exponential plus linear, polynomial, and user
defined functions. All currently
accepted methods are implemented.
Please refer to the description of FirstLight for details. Of particular importance is the new
script-based data taking, which permits very easy implementation of complex
measurement protocols, without having to enter data about each measurement
cycle.
3. Computer
system. While a simple 386SX system
(if you can still find one!) is perfectly adequate to run the DOS version of
TLAPPLIC, a minimum of a Pentium II at 200 MHz is preferred since it most
likely will serve other purposes in the lab as well, and is required for
FirstLight. A dot matrix or
laser/inkjet printer is needed for output.
4. Oven
atmosphere control. The glow oven
must be evacuated, and then purged with a flow of oxygen- and water vapor-free
gas to reduce spurious light signals from the sample. A two-stage vacuum pump of 50-100 liter/minute free air capacity
is necessary. An Alcatel 205DSM is
recommended as a very sturdy, quiet vacuum pump that should last forever if you
change oil frequently. A source of high
purity inert gas, nitrogen or argon, is
required as a purge and cooling gas.
Its purity should be at least 99.999%.
Pre-purified grade of nitrogen is sufficient for most purposes. A two-stage regulator (for precise control)
is much preferred over the somewhat less expensive single stage variety, and a
flowmeter is needed to set and monitor the purge gas flow rate (approximately
2-4 liters/minute). Omega Engineering
makes an inexpensive flowmeter that is suitable. DO NOT get a flow
regulator, as the pressure in the purge gas line gets very high when the purge
and cooling gas control valves are
turned off, resulting in a "puff" that could disturb the samples when
the valves open.
5. Irradiation
system. It is necessary to have
both beta (or gamma) and alpha comparison doses to determine the growth curves
of the samples being dated; the reason being that the alpha sensitivity varies
a good deal between samples, from 0.02 to 0.40 times the beta (or gamma)
sensitivity. It is necessary to get
both beta and alpha growth curves for all samples. The 100 mCi Sr-90 and 250 mCi
Am-241 sealed sources are appropriate for archaeological dating. If suitable irradiation facilities are
available locally, it would be possible to irradiate samples outside the lab
for later measurement. It is, however,
very much preferable to have your own sources dedicated to TL The 801 multiple sample irradiator is preferred
for the reasons mentioned above, but the two-position sample elevator with
irradiation port, together with the 740 and 750 irradiators plus sources do
present a significant cost savings (about $3000). This savings is reduced if you purchase the 770 beta transfer
mechanism, which reduces greatly the increased dark count that results from the
close proximity of the beta source to the PMT when the irradiator is in place
on the TL reader system. In situations where
the signal level is low, and it is convenient (or necessary) to do beta
irradiations during the measurements, the 770 is a necessity.
6. Alpha counting system. The major source of radiation dose
contributing to the TL of a sample is the uranium and thorium in the pottery
itself, and in the surrounding soil.
The easiest and most cost-effective means of determining U and Th
content is by alpha counting, whereby the alpha activity is measured directly,
and the beta and gamma contributions are computed. Since, worldwide, U and Th concentrations may vary by an order of
magnitude, alpha counting should be done for every sample. The 583 counter has pairs detection and
counting, in addition to the usual totals count, and the U/Th ratio may be
determined for increased dating precision in demanding dating programs. The 583 is a printing data logger that also
does data reduction, computing the count rate and its uncertainty, plus the
U/Th ratio. It has battery-protected
memory to save data in case of power failure, although running the counter from
an uninterruptible power supply is recommended for power conditioning if the AC
line is prone to fluctuations. For high
precision, samples on ZnS scintillator screens deposited on mylar and used in
sealed counting cells are counted unsealed and then sealed to determine effects
of radon loss. For routine
authenticity dating, ZnS powder is dusted on cellophane tape in plastic rings
for inexpensive scintillator cells. It
is recommended that 2-3 sealed cells per counter, plus a supply of scintillator
screens be purchased. Counting time
will vary from 6 hours to 4-6 days depending on the counting precision
desired. For many clays, alpha activity
is about 6 counts per kilosecond for a 43 mm scintillator. Eventually, more than a single counter will
be needed. The current production is a new standalone model that replaces the
now-retired modular packaging. The
module packaging will be available while existing stocks of case parts remain,
for those wanting to fill existing slots in their 503 enclosures.
7.
Potassium measurement. Beta and
gamma dose from K-40 may contribute 10-50 per cent of the total dose rate, so
that potassium measurement is necessary for precise dating (although an
approximate range is generally sufficient for authenticity dating). While an atomic absorption spectrometer or
flame photometer and appropriate sample preparation apparatus would be
desirable, it probably would be more
cost-effective to have these measurements done outside the lab. This measurement is simple and fairly inexpensive.
8. Alternative
doserate measurements. While
traditionally, dose rates have been computed from alpha count rates and
potassium content, there are other means available. For example, gamma spectrometers are sometimes used to make
measurements of the U, Th, and K content of samples and soils. Portable gamma counters (four-channel or
multichannel analyzers) and now commonly used for making direct environmental
dose rate measurements in the field.
Beta counters of various types have been successfuly used also. Unfortunately, all these methods are in
the luxury category on account of cost,
so most workers in the field start out with just an alpha counter.
9. Other equipment. A small amount of additional equipment is
needed, mostly for sample preparation.
Samples are either drilled (from art objects) powder or crushed
sherds. A small highspeed drill or
flexible shaft motor with carbide burrs is needed for sample drilling and
cleaning. Some inexpensive hobby drills
are quite suitable. For crushing
sherds, a vise with a stainless steel
sheet V-shaped trough to crush and catch the powdered pottery is a simple
solution. Samples are prepared by
sedimentation in acetone and then deposited on aluminum or stainless steel
disks. For this, some glassware is
needed--test tubes and shell vials, and sample disks (we can provide aluminum
sheet and a punch for cheaply making disposible disks, although some workers
prefer stainless steel), and finally an oven for drying the sample disks. A simple lab drying oven is suitable. An automatic pipettor (0.5 ml) with a supply
of tips is really necessary here. An
inexpensive one like the lower-priced Centaur West models is fine. Lighting in the lab must be very low,
and contain no UV component. Red or
amber photographic safelights are suitable, as are fluorescent lamps covered
with red or amber filters. Low pressure
sodium lamps are increasingly used in many laboratories. For OSL measurements, lighting requirements
are extremely stringent, as both UV/blue/green AND IR ambient light are a
problem. Special sample preparation
techniques are necessary for problem materials, where spurious light emission
from the sample interferes with measurements of the radiation-induced TL, and fine grain dating is inappropriate. Here, coarse grain dating is indicated and
some means of mineral separation is useful after crushing and sieving (to
remove the clumps of iron- bearing fine grains that cause the problem). The usual apparatus is the Frantz magnetic
separator that is very often found in geology departments, and so may not need
to be purchased.
SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS FOR SEDIMENT
DATING
TL dating of sun-bleached sediments requires a
zeroing step in the course of the measurements. For sediment dating by optical bleaching methods, the one
indispensible piece of equipment needed in addition to that necessary for
pottery dating is a solar simulator for bleaching samples. This may be as simple as a Hg tanning lamp
mounted in a box with fixed lamp to sample distance and perhaps a broadband
interference filter set for investigating bleaching response as a function of
wavelength. Or, if your budget permits,
we offer the Sol 2 solar simulator from Dr K. Hönle GmbH in Germany, as an excellent
choice. This should be ordered with the
H2 filter and a spare lamp. Because
the number of sample disks used in sediment dating is greatly increased over
pottery dating, it is well worth considering the Daybreak model 1150 TL reader
system which has a 57-sample capacity (by stacking three sample platters) for
only a small increase in price. This
instrument does have the limitation that irradiators may not be fitted to
it. For the most part, this should not be
a limitation in practice, except for certain specialized methods (pre-dose dating
and single aliquot OSL dating).
OSL dating, which measures only the bleachable
electron population, does the optical bleaching during the course of complete
shinedowns. This avoids the problem of
determining the fraction of unbleachable TL signal, since the unbleachable
population is never detected, and makes life considerable simpler, especially
for young and partially bleached sediments.
Because of this, OSL dating has now almost completely supplanted TL, and
there is little use for TL in sediment dating except in some techniques like
single aliquot regenerative, where sensitivity changes may be monitored by
recording low temperature TL during the course of ramping up to a preheat
temperature. The low temperature TL is
not subject to interference by spurious TL signals, so the 2200 OSL-only system
(fitted with the nichrome sample stage) will serve to do this. While it is certainly worthwhile retaining
TL measurement capability in the laboratory for those few cases where it is
necessary, the lower price and greater simplicity (and ease of service) of an
OSL-only system is very much worth considering. It should be noted that with the optional purge gas inlet and
control, the 2200 may be used for many TL measurements, even though it cannot
be evacuated.
OPTICALLY STIMULATED LUMINESCENCE
Since TL and OSL reader systems share almost all
their constituent elements, the most economical means of setting up a
combination TL/OSL dating lab is to add the excitation light source as an
accessory to a TL reader. To that end,
Daybreak offers a number of solutions. The 1100IR/G all solid-state combination
IR and green (or blue) OSL exciter is the best choice, superceding all earlier
models for general purpose dating. Both
IR and blue (or green)excitation power is completely programmable from zero to
full intensity (50 mW/cm2 for IR, and 60 mW/cm2 for
blue). Both IR and blue LED arrays have
internal glass blocking filters to reduce detector background. There is, of course, zero maintenance (no
lamp replacement). The other possible OSL options are described in the
specification supplement. For those
interested in OSL alone, the 2200, a new high capacity OSL reader, optimized
for OSL, is the best choice. This unit
has a number of useful features, including 60-sample removable platter, two
temperature controlled stages, one for detection which may be either one based
on a thermoelectric module for stable sample temperature in the 0-200C range
(that is, cooling as well as heating) or on a nichrome heating plate for
ambient to 500C (so TL is possible); the other (optionally heated) is the
irradiation stage for elevated temperature irradiations, making preheats
unnecessary. The 2200 has additional
control of OSL measurement timebase, and supports linear ramping of OSL
excitation power. It supports the IRIS4
quad detector, especially useful for IROSL, and the new single grain array
green laser scanner that measures more than 80 grains on a single sample disk. The grains are irradiated simultaneously,
saving considerable time.